Understanding the main idea of a piece of writing is probably the most important aspect of reading once children understand phonics. Yet many children struggle to find the main idea. How can we help them?
- Ask the children to read the title and any subheadings. Ask the children what those words mean. Ask the children to predict what the writing might be about.
- Ask the children to look at any graphics such as photos, graphs, charts, maps, diagrams or other nontextual information. Ask the children what they have learned from those graphics. Ask them to predict what the reading might be about.
- In nonfiction, the main idea is often expressed at the end of the first paragraph. Ask the children if the last sentence of the first paragraph tells what the main idea is.
- In nonfiction, many times the first paragraph or even two or three paragraphs are a hook. They might give hints about the topic of the writing, but they might not tell the main idea. Ask the children if that is the case with what they are reading.
- In nonfiction, topic sentences often start the body paragraphs of a reading. Ask the child to read the first sentences of the body paragraphs. Are they topic sentences? If so, what is the topic that they are giving details about?
- In the last paragraph of nonfiction, the main idea is often repeated. Ask the children to read the last paragraph and to identify the main idea if it is there.
- Reading the first important paragraph (not the hook) and the last paragraph, one right after another, can sometimes help children to discover the main idea. Do both paragraphs talk about the same thing? If so, what is it?
Some children will understand immediately while others will need many, many lessons focused on the main idea. If children need more examples, more tries at figuring it out, make sure they get those extra examples and time. Figuring out the main idea will be on almost every reading test they ever take from first grade to the SATs.
But more importantly, it is a life skill which they will need.
Sometimes we think vocabulary words are the kinds found in good literature, words like “evade,” “grandeur” and “prescient.”
But many times the words children must learn are the basic words and phrases of the subjects they learn in school, words like “remainder,” “summarize” and “find the function of.”
When children are in pre-K they are taught words like “thicker than,” “thinner than,” “shorter than,” and “taller than.” We parents and teachers take the time to instruct about these terms and then to quiz the children informally to be sure they understand.
But as children age, some terms fall through the cracks. The third grade teacher assumes that the second grade teacher has taught words related to subtraction, such as “difference” and “minus.” And the second grade teacher probably has. But what if a child was sick that day, or was distracted, or was moving from one school to another?
I was reminded of this when the mother of a middle schooler told me her son was having trouble figuring out some math terms, including “at most,” “at least,” “no more than,” “no fewer than,” “maximum,” “minimum” and “below.”
Her remarks reminded me of my own trouble learning what “function” meant in my algebra class. Whatever my teacher said didn’t help me, and for weeks I was confounded by that word.
How can we help our children learn the vocabulary basic to the subjects they are studying in school?
- When a child starts a new learning skill, such a multiplication, or a new unit, such as erosion, teach the vocabulary the child will need to know. Page through the child’s text to see what words are used. Then quiz the child on the vocabulary, both informally and formally. Make definitions part of subject matter testing. Be sure to use domain-specific words, such as “factor” and “water cycle” as well as informal words.
- Regularly review vocabulary in a field of study. You could offer a “spelling” bee reviewing definitions of volcanic terms, such as lava, molten, intrusive, extrusive, ring of fire and magma. You could play a BINGO game based on figures of speech, such as simile, metaphor, hyperbole and personification.
- Ask students to create dictionaries of terms they need to know in order to talk about a subject. Instruct students to read their dictionaries for two minutes before each day’s instruction on that topic.
- Give pretests which include definitions.
- Be aware of students who are absent when you teach vocabulary and give them private lessons or ask an advanced student to catch the laggard up.
- In emails home to parents, name new words the child needs to know and ask parents to discuss these words to reinforce them.
One of the key skills in reading well is learning and remembering vocabulary.
Creating mind webs (also called spider webs and concept maps) is a great way to increase comprehension for child readers. Mind webs should be created while the child is reading. Details can be added after each paragraph if the paragraph is rich in detail. Or they can be added after a page or a chapter. The length of the reading can determine how often the student adds to the mind web.
How does this strategy work?
- First, on a piece of notebook paper, the child writes the topic in the center and encircles it. For a child not used to this strategy, an adult might draw three or four “spokes” from the center, and at the end of each spoke, write an idea that the child should note while reading. For example, if a child is reading a biography about George Washington, one spoke might be labeled “childhood” or “education.” Another might be labeled “family.” Another could be called “soldier” or “general.” And the last might be called “President.”
- After the ideas are determined, the child begins reading. As he reads about Washington’s family, the child might write down the names of important family members, what happened to them, or how they influenced him. For example, Washington’s father died when he was a child. His older brother cared for him, but then Washington had to care for his brother when he became sick. Next to “President,” the child could write the year Washington became president, people who helped him, why he was an important president.
- Sometimes details in one category connect to details in other categories. Students can show this by drawing lines to connect the details. For example, when he was a soldier, Washington hired Alexander Hamilton to be his aide. Later he picked Hamilton to be a helper when he was President.
For reluctant readers, a parent or teacher might need to work one-on-one, helping the child to create the mind web. For a group, the teacher could model the concept by drawing a mind web on the board or on a computer whose image is projected, and by jotting down suggestions from students.
Sometimes children will write laundry lists of facts on a mind web. A parent or teacher should probe about those facts and encourage the child to detail why each fact is important. It is better to have fewer subdivisions but more details for each one than a long list without details. Why was one of Washington’s helpers Hamilton? Why was Washington’s work as a soldier when he was 21 important later on?
To reinforce the comprehension, the students could write one or more paragraphs, using the mind web for information.
Mind webs can aid reading comprehension in any subject. They help children organize information and see connections. Because they are informally drawn and can be added to at any time, they can enlarge as the child’s knowledge enlarges.
The US Department of Education has put together a list of accomplishments* relating to talking and reading for children from birth to six years old. This list shows the growth of typical children developing normally, but variations exist. By seven years old, most children are reading.
From birth to age 3, most babies and toddlers become able to
- Make sounds that imitate the tones and rhythms that adults use when talking.
- Respond to gestures and facial expressions.
- Begin to associate words they hear frequently with what the words mean.
- Make cooing, babbling sounds in the crib, which gives way to enjoying rhyming and nonsense word games with a parent or caregiver.
- Play along in games such as “peek-a-boo” and “pat-a-cake.”
- Handle objects such as board books and alphabet blocks in their play.
- Recognize certain books by their covers.
- Pretend to read books.
- Understand how books should be handled.
- Share books with an adult as a routine part of life.
- Name some objects in a book.
- Talk about characters in books.
- Look at pictures in books and realize they are symbols of real things.
- Listen to stories.
- Ask or demand that adults read or write with them.
- Begin to pay attention to specific print such as the first letters of their names.
- Scribble with a purpose (trying to write or draw something).
- Produce some letter-like forms and scribbles that resemble, in some way, writing.
From ages 3-4, most preschoolers become able to
- Enjoy listening to and talking about storybooks.
- Understand that print carries a message.
- Make attempts to read and write.
- Identify familiar signs and labels.
- Participate in rhyming games.
- Identify some letters and make some letter-sound matches.
- Use known letters (or their best attempt to write the letters) to represent written language especially for meaningful words like their names or phrases such as “I love you.”
At age 5, most kindergartners become able to
- Sound as if they are reading when they pretend to read.
- Enjoy being read to.
- Retell simple stories.
- Use descriptive language to explain or to ask questions.
- Recognize letters and letter-sound matches.
- Show familiarity with rhyming and beginning sounds.
- Understand that print is read left-to-right and top-to-bottom.
- Begin to match spoken words with written ones.
- Begin to write letters of the alphabet and some words they use and hear often.
- Begin to write stories with some readable parts.
At age 6, most first-graders can
- Read and retell familiar stories.
- Use a variety of ways to help with reading a story such as rereading, predicting what will happen, asking questions, or using visual cues or pictures.
- Decide on their own to use reading and writing for different purposes;
- Read some things aloud with ease.
- Identify new words by using letter-sound matches, parts of words and their understanding of the rest of a story or printed item.
- Identify an increasing number of words by sight.
- Sound out and represent major sounds in a word when trying to spell.
- Write about topics that mean a lot to them.
- Try to use some punctuation marks and capitalization.
*Based on information from Preventing Reading Difficulties in Young Children, a report of the National Research Council, by the Committee on the Prevention of Reading Difficulties in Young Children, 1998; and from the Joint Position Statement of the International Reading Association (IRA) and the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC), 1998.
Posted in ABC's, asking questions, kindergarten readiness, learning in infancy, letter sounds, literacy, phonics, picture books, reading readiness., reading research, US education
Audio books, also called books on tape, are a great way for busy adults to “read.” Pop one in your car CD player for a long commute. Listen while you make dinner or wait through a long soccer practice.
But are they good for your young children? Yes and No.
- Yes, if you speak English with an accent and want your child read to by native English speakers.
- Yes, if you want to encourage reading but you are too busy making dinner or bathing the baby to read to your preschooler.
- Yes, if you are looking for an educational alternative to video games, electronic games or TV.
- Yes, if your child is a beginning reader or a poor reader who could benefit from hearing the same book read multiple times while reading along.
- Yes, if you need a bedtime ritual for your child which doesn’t involve you or which takes the place of you when you work late or travel.
But sometimes video books are not a good choice.
- No, if you think video books can take the place of your reading to your child on a regular basis.
- No, if your child has questions, or wants to pause to look longer at the pictures.
- No, if the pacing of the book is too fast for the child, or the language too advanced, or the themes too mature.
- No, if you hope your struggling reader will read along rather than merely listen to the voice on the machine.
- No, if the background music, sound effects or dramatic flair of the reader grate on your child’s nerves.
I have been in classrooms where some children listen intently to audio books while others tune out. If your child is struggling to read or is generally restless, you might need to join him while he listens to audio books to keep him focused.
Audio books isolate a child. Children learn better when they have a strong positive emotional connection to the learning process. When a parent reads to a child, cuddling, answering her questions, pausing until she is ready to move on, explaining new words, roaring with wild thing noises or laughing at a cat in a hat, the child engages and learns to a greater degree than is possible with audio books.
Audio books can work well to supplement, but they cannot replace your reading to your child.
Because no national student tests focus on spelling only, experts can’t say how widespread spelling problems are. But ask any teacher, and she will tell you many, many children learn to spell with difficulty or depend on phonetic spellings.
If you are the parent or teacher of such a child, what do you do?
Here’s what doesn’t work.
- Teaching spelling rules rarely works. When students see a worksheet or test on one aspect of spelling, they can do okay. That’s because they are focusing on one rule of spelling. But if you test on several rules, or wait a week to retest on one rule, a poor speller makes numerous mistakes. And if you ask the child to write a few sentences with words which use some of these spelling rules, spelling errors abound. It’s as if you never taught the rules.
- Having the child memorize often used words can work if the word is simple. But not always. Many children spell “went” as “whent,” or confuse “then” and “than,” or use “b” for “d,” or spell “was” as “saw.” These children might have great visual memories for colors and landmarks, but not for spelling. Experts think this is because the brain’s “wiring” for spelling is part of the language processing part of the brain. Poor spelling is one sign of underlying language processing problems.
- Teaching word parts—prefixes, suffixes and roots—can help a child guess at the meaning of words, but it doesn’t help much with spelling. The child will say the word in her mind and spell it the way it sounds to her. “Useful” might come out “youzful.”
Here’s what does work.
- Accommodations, especially allowing the child to use electronic writing equipment, reduce some but not all spelling errors. Spellcheck alerts the child that a word has been misspelled. She can click on the misspelled word and the correct spelling appears. She clicks on the correct spelling and eliminates the problem. You might think: but then she will never learn correct spelling. But how about you? When you make a spelling error on your computer or phone, don’t you click and replace? So why shouldn’t a student? Because of ubiquitous technology, the same rules which applied to us when we were students shouldn’t necessarily apply to students today. The SAT allows calculators. It didn’t when I took the test.
- Teachers who limit the number of points off for spelling errors would lessen the stress on poor spellers. What if teachers would limit the percentage of a writing grade devoted to spelling to 5%, no matter how many words are misspelled? Spelling is a way of delivering a message, the same as sentence structure and vocabulary and type faces. If teachers would focus more on the content of writing, on its organization and message, and focus less on spelling and handwriting, poor spelling would be less of an issue.
- If a child focuses on learning the spelling of the 100 or 200 most commonly used words in English, and ignores the rest, her spelling would improve. If those “most used” words were posted in the classroom as a universal word bank available to any child any time, spelling would improve. Or those words could be offered to each child in a little booklet which the child could keep in her desk and refer to at any time. Why not? Do you remember every one of your relative’s phone numbers anymore? Or do you let your smart phone remember for you? Is it “cheating” for you to press a name rather than to key in a ten-digit phone number? Then why can’t a child look up a spelling word?
English is a tough language to spell–maybe the toughest. So many rules, so many exemptions. Let’s take away some of the energy that goes into spelling correctly and put it into more important skills, like writing well.
So you suspect your preschooler has dyslexia. What can you do?
- Realize that the younger a child is when identified as dyslexic, the sooner help can begin. If possible, you want to identify the situation before the child becomes frustrated and discouraged, and before the child is labeled as “different.”
- Ask your school district to test the child. Because of the child’s age, the district might balk, and say he will be tested when in kindergarten, or first grade, or later. Sometimes the district will become involved if you have some “proof” that the child is dyslexic. This might require private testing at your expense by some recognized expert.
- From the school district, find out what services your child will receive and when.
- If the school district “officially” won’t help, make an appointment with your elementary school’s reading specialist. She will probably have ideas you can start with, and she might be able to lend you materials or at least identify materials that will help.
- Consider hiring a reading tutor, one with experience teaching children with dyslexia. A good tutor will use many strategies, particularly game-like, hands-on approaches that will appeal to a preschooler.
- If someone else in the immediate family has dyslexia, there’s a good chance your child has the same kind of reading problem and can be helped the same way. What worked for your other relative?
- Check out ideas on the internet. Use keywords such as dyslexia, preschooler, reading and learning strategies.
- Begin working with your child yourself. Focus on the sounds of the language first, and make sure your child can hear them and pronounce them properly. Only then match sounds with letters.
- Is letter recognition difficult? Buy an ABC puzzle or letter tiles or a Scrabble game. Use the letters to play games forcing the child to identify letters. Unfortunately, most sources for letters use only capital letters, and it is generally lower case letters which cause problems.
- Work on printing letters properly. If fine motor coordination is difficult, use a computer keyboard instead. But again, most keyboards identify the keys with capital letters.
- Use music. Teach your child the ABC song. Sing songs together which rhyme or read nursery rhymes.
- Teach directions. Up, down. Left, right. Inside, outside.
- You may find it takes longer for your dyslexic child to master certain skills when compared to a child without reading difficulties. Be patient. If a younger sibling is catching on faster than the dyslexic child, work with each child independently and out of earshot from one another. If at all possible, conceal from your child that he is having reading difficulties. Find ways for him to succeed at learning.
How about pulling your child out of preschool, or stopping all reading instruction for a year or until the child is seven or until the child reaches first grade? These are not good solutions. In pre-K students are expected to know their letter sounds and to match them with ABC’s. In kindergarten children are expected to read CVC words, high frequency words, and some two-syllable words. A child who can’t keep up with his classmates develops low self-esteem which can intensify reading problems.
Be proactive. If you think your three or four-yer-old shows signs of reading difficulty, act as soon as possible for the best outcome.