If you are trying to assess whether your student, especially your English Language Learner, can understand what she is reading, use cloze activities.
Cloze activities are written passages with words left out. Students need to supply the missing words. Sometimes random words are omitted—such as every seventh word—and a blank space replaces a missing word. Sometimes a particular part of speech is omitted. Sometimes words that are important for the structure of a sentence, like prepositions, are omitted.
Let’s take a paragraph and show several cloze variations which yield particular information about a student’s reading comprehension.
This morning, I woke up early and slipped downstairs to play with the new puppy. Max was in a cage, so I opened it, and let him out. Quickly I took him to the back of the yard where he knew what to do. I threw a ball which he liked and a rubber bone which he didn’t like. Then we came inside and I fixed him a simple breakfast.
Now suppose we leave out every eighth word of the above paragraph. Here is the result.
This morning, I woke up early and _______ downstairs to play with the new puppy. ________ was in a cage, so I opened ________, and let him out. Quickly I took _______ to the back of the yard where ________ knew what to do. I threw a ________ which he liked and a rubber bone _______ he didn’t like. Then we came inside ________ I fixed him a simple breakfast.
Depending on the word choices the student makes, you can learn if the student understands the meaning of the paragraph. You can ask her to justify her choice by explaining which context clues she used.
Now suppose we try a different cloze paragraph, this time leaving out all pronouns.
This morning, _______ woke up early and slipped downstairs to play with the new puppy. Max was in a cage, so _______ opened _______, and let _______ out. Quickly _______ took _______ to the back of the yard where _______ knew what to do. _______ threw a ball which _______ liked and a rubber bone which _______ didn’t like. Then _______ came inside and _______ fixed him a simple breakfast.
From this exercise, you can learn whether the student knows both subject and object pronouns and when to use them.
Now suppose you are testing appropriate use of articles. You can remove all articles, and in addition, put spaces before all nouns or adjective-noun groups to see if the student knows whether articles are needed and if so, which articles are needed.
This morning, I woke up early and slipped downstairs to play with _______ new puppy. _______ Max was in _______ cage, so I opened it, and let him out. Quickly I took him to _______back of _______ yard where he knew what to do. I threw _______ ball which he liked and _______ rubber bone which he didn’t like. Then we came inside and I fixed him _______ simple breakfast.
If a student is studying vocabulary, a word bank can be supplied and from those words the student chooses words to fill in the blanks.
Before you use a cloze activity, know what you are testing for and then create or find a cloze activity which will yield that kind of information.